Ruling by Justice Deepak Roshan’s Bench; Directive to Exclude Candidates Found Guilty During Investigation Remains in Force
Ranchi: The Jharkhand High Court has quashed the state government’s order to cancel the Jharkhand Staff Selection Commission (JSSC) Combined Graduate Level (CGL-2023) examination (Advertisement No. 10/2023). In a judgment delivered on Friday, the bench of Justice Deepak Roshan set aside the state government’s notification issued on August 18, 2026. This decision brings relief to approximately 1,932 successful candidates, who will now retain their government jobs.
In its ruling, the Court clarified that the guidelines previously issued by the Supreme Court in this matter remain in effect. Candidates identified as guilty during the investigation must be excluded from employment. The Court emphasized that neither the state government nor the relevant authorities can bypass the Supreme Court’s directives.
Also Read: ONTHHPC Crowned Champions of 54th Nehru Junior Hockey Tournament After Three Years
Cancellation of the Entire Examination Deemed Unjustified
The Court observed that the state government’s decision to cancel the advertisement does not align with the judgments delivered by the Jharkhand High Court and the Supreme Court in the case of Prakash Kumar and Others. Canceling the entire examination without completing the investigation is not justified; all appointments cannot be terminated without distinguishing between guilty and innocent candidates.
According to the Court, it would be improper to remove candidates who have already been appointed from service without following the prescribed procedure and completing a thorough investigation. It is noteworthy that the Supreme Court had previously directed that any candidates found guilty during the investigation must be denied appointment.
Court Delivers Verdict on Three Petitions
The court of Justice Deepak Roshan delivered its verdict on separate petitions filed by Ramesh Oraon and others, Akash Gaurav and others, and Niroj Khes and others, all of whom challenged the decision to cancel the JSSC-CGL recruitment process.
Also Read: DPS Ranchi Honours 145 Primary Wing Students for Academic Excellence
Senior Advocate Meenakshi Arora represented the State Government, while Senior Advocate Rajeev Ranjan and advocates Gopal Shankarnarayanan, Indrajit Sinha, and Amritansh Vats presented arguments on behalf of the petitioners.
Government Cites Large-Scale Irregularities in the Examination
During earlier hearings, the petitioners informed the court that the matter concerning the JSSC-CGL had already been addressed by both the High Court and the Supreme Court. Those courts had directed that a distinction be made between guilty and innocent candidates, and that any decisions regarding recruitment should be based on the findings of a criminal investigation. Given this, the petitioners argued that there was no justification for cancelling the recruitment process once again.
The petitioners contended that the decision to cancel the examination amounted to contempt of the court’s previous orders, alleging that the government had taken this step merely to appease protesting students.
Conversely, the State Government argued that the examination was marred by large-scale irregularities and corruption. It was alleged that the agency responsible for conducting the examination allowed the question paper to be leaked. Furthermore, it was claimed that, through this agency, candidates were taken to locations such as Nepal, where they were provided with the answers to the questions—a process that severely compromised the transparency of the examination.
The government submitted to the court that it was essential to maintain public trust in the recruitment process. Investigations had uncovered concrete evidence of irregularities and corruption. According to the government, it was not feasible to distinguish between the guilty and the innocent candidates. Consequently, in light of the question paper leak and other irregularities, the Cabinet decided to cancel the entire examination.
Related News
- Jharkhand ONTHHPC Crowned Champions of 54th Nehru Junior Hockey Tournament After Three Years
- Jharkhand DPS Ranchi Honours 145 Primary Wing Students for Academic Excellence
- Jharkhand Preservation of the Traditions, Culture, and Identity of the Tribal Community is Essential: Chief Minister Hemant Soren
- Jharkhand Jharkhand Gramin Bank Officials Meet CM Hemant Soren, Discuss Expansion of Banking Services












