Skip to content
Log In

Election Commission SIR: Sandhu and Joshi Filed 14 Written Objections Over Voter Roll Decisions

Election Commission of India and electoral roll revision during the SIR process
Election Commission officials during the ongoing debate over electoral roll revision and SIR.

New Delhi: Objections raised within the Election Commission of India (ECI) regarding the revision of electoral rolls have brought the Commission’s internal functioning into the spotlight. According to an investigative report by The Indian Express, two Election Commissioners—Sukhbir Singh Sandhu and Vivek Joshi—registered written objections at least 14 times over the past 10 months. These instances include an occasion where four objections were lodged on a single day.

The report states that the objections raised by the two commissioners concerned issues such as new voter registrations, the deletion and restoration of names, appeals related to the SIR (Summary Revision) process, and the security and management of electoral voter data. Copies of these objections were also sent to Chief Election Commissioner Gyanesh Kumar.

Also Read: On November 16, Delhi Metro will begin operations for Chhath Puja at 4:30 AM

Questions Raised on the Process of Adding New Voters

According to The Indian Express report, Sukhbir Singh Sandhu alleged in a written objection that the Commission acted contrary to the written advice of the two Election Commissioners. The report notes that Sandhu described the move in question as “unauthorised” and “illegal.” This matter pertained to the process of registering new voters and changes made to Form 6.

Form 6 is used for registration as a new voter. The report indicates that both commissioners objected to the changes made to Form 6, stating that such modifications required amendments to the relevant rules.

Also Read: 96.47 kg Ganja Seized at Assam-Arunachal Border, Vehicle Driver Absconds

Concerns Raised Regarding the Voter Database

The report also highlights objections raised by the two commissioners concerning the digital management of electoral voter data. They reportedly expressed concern that control over access to the voter database was becoming overly centralized within a Delhi-based system, potentially undermining the roles of state and local-level officials.

Both commissioners also raised questions regarding the monitoring and security of the IT systems associated with the electoral rolls. According to the report, they subsequently sent separate letters to the Cabinet Secretary regarding this issue. Over 13 Crore Names Removed from Draft Rolls During SIR

This development emerged during the Election Commission’s Special Intensive Revision (SIR) process. According to The Indian Express, the SIR process—which began in Bihar in June 2025—was subsequently extended to 30 states and Union Territories, resulting in the removal of over 13 crore names from the draft electoral rolls.

The objective of the SIR is to revise and update electoral rolls and verify the records of eligible voters. During this process, several administrative questions arose regarding the addition, deletion, and reinstatement of voters’ names.

Case Regarding Appeals Concerning Voter Names in Bengal

The report also mentions a case from West Bengal, raising questions about the process of filing appeals regarding a large number of voter names. According to an India Today report, Sandhu had sought information from officials regarding who—and at what level—had been authorized by the Commission to file these appeals.

What Did the Election Commission Say?

Following reports of objections raised by two Election Commissioners, the Election Commission dismissed any notion of internal discord or unilateral action in its decision-making process. The Commission stated that differing opinions and comments are part of the standard consultative process within any institution, and such remarks may be recorded prior to a final decision being reached.

The Commission further asserted that all decisions taken over the past year, including the SIR, were unanimous decisions of the full Commission. According to the Commission, focusing on select internal comments fails to present the complete picture regarding the decisions and approvals made.

The Commission also stated that its digital platforms and systems related to electoral data operate under stringent data security protocols, and all its actions are in compliance with the law.

What Is Currently Being Discussed? The 14 written objections revealed by The Indian Express investigation primarily relate to voter registration, the deletion and restoration of names, changes to Form 6, access to the voter database, and administrative decisions concerning the SIR. Meanwhile, the Election Commission maintains that such observations are part of the decision-making process and that final decisions were reached through consensus.

The administrative and legal implications of these objections can only be assessed based on the documents that have come to light and the Commission’s official stance on the matter.

Naman Sinha Author

Related News

Leave a Comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *